This picture is one I took at the protest outside a Leeds hotel for asylum seekers. The anti-immigrant protestors and their pro-immigrant opponents go there every Friday with their loudspeakers to chant their denunciations of each other.
On this occasion the two sides were able to get closer to each other than they had on previous Fridays, so more police had been called in. The police I spoke to seemed quite happy; one said it was a pleasant change from work at the office.
For a while the pro-immigrant protestors were chanting ‘Refugees are welcome here’. When I got close to the other side, my hearing isn’t great but they seemed to be chanting the same thing. Maybe it was ‘Refugees aren’t welcome here’.
I had gone to see for myself what happens when Heston Groenewald, the Vicar of All Hallows Church, turns up. He, like me, is happy to welcome immigrants, but he expresses it by turning up to the anti-immigrant protestors and talking to them. On other occasions he has handed out biscuits and cakes – sometimes accompanied by an Islamic friend. This time it was chocolates. I went with him and listened to a woman who had previously worked at the hotel, looking after the asylum seekers. She had some stories to tell. We listened sympathetically.
I went home asking myself: is this a microcosm of society? All the loudspeaker-enhanced chanting dominated the proceedings, but only came from about half a dozen people on each side. Behind them, on each side, their supporters stood around chatting.
Nehanyahu and Hamas. Russia and Ukraine. The denunciations come from a minority on both sides. The majority can be persuaded to support one side but otherwise would rather live in peace.
All through history, denouncing enemies has been a ruling class tool, a justification for taking from the ordinary people to enrich the elite.
What if we turned that picture round by 90 degrees? What if, instead of siding with Ukraine against Russia or Gaza against Israel, we sided with the peacemakers against the warmakers? What if the most belligerent governments went to the other side, handed out chocolates and listened to their stories?