John and his disciple Jesus

This is an extract from my book How Jesus Liberated the Oppressed.

John the Baptist, like many earlier prophets, foretold God’s judgement on the rich for exploiting the poor. Jesus, by accepting baptism at his hands, showed that he stood in John’s tradition. But he did things differently. John expected imminent change brought about by God: the end was nigh! In practice it was a disabling theory. On the one hand one was to be dissatisfied; on the other, all one could do was to wait for God to make changes. Jesus, instead, began a movement where people actively worked to change things. This implies that he did not anticipate divine intervention. Scholars still debate the question, but here I am following those who think he expected the world to carry on as it was.

John, like many earlier prophets, emphasized what was wrong with the current state of affairs and expressed his disapproval by dressing in rags and fasting. Jesus went to parties and was happy to enjoy himself living in the present. The gospels tell us that like John he was in constant conflict with the ruling classes, but unlike John he was open to discussing things with them and sometimes agreed with them…

As the pressure of debt increased, people became more desperate. In each village some would have lent money to a neighbor and urgently needed it back, while the neighbor had no means to repay. People would remember with resentment the past occasions when a favor had not been repaid. Quarrels would have developed. Neighbors would have fallen out with each other and declined requests for help. The traditional solidarity of peasant villages was breaking down. Just as today the political establishment often tells the impoverished to put the blame on other impoverished people—refugees or benefit claimants—so also in first-century Galilee the dominant elite could persuade those in the greatest distress to blame each other. By talking to people about the renewal of Israel within the villages where they lived, Jesus could encourage them to hear each other’s stories and appreciate that they were all in the same boat. They could then discuss with each other how to respond to the situation by supporting each other…

It was John who preached as an individual. Like the prophets of the Hebrew scriptures he saw himself as speaking on behalf of God. Jesus, by contrast, worked collaboratively. He invited those hungry people to discuss what to do and share the work. For example, a lot of what the gospels tell us is about the questions he asked.