You too could display a poster supporting Palestine Action.
Do you think it would be the right thing to do? If you don’t, is that because you think it would be the wrong thing to do, or do you just prefer not to get arrested?
Now that it has been added to the British list of ‘proscribed organisations’ the number of people arrested for displaying such posters has been going up.
The way we humans have evolved, most of us go along with the consensus of our community but others like to think things through. In general it’s a good thing. Every society needs lots of people who just get on doing the work, but also needs some people to think through which work needs doing. If you get stuck into one issue, you will have to leave it to others to get stuck into the other issues.
So are you the kind of person who disapproves of protestors in general, or does it depend on the specific issue? Do you presuppose that people should obey the law? Does that mean laws are morally good, or do you allow for a moral authority that transcends the law? Like God, or ‘human rights’?
Or do you think the public have a duty to stand up for what is right? In which case, what is right? If you are inclined to go along with the consensus, how do you feel when the dominant consensus disagrees with what the decision-makers are doing? Here we are in one such situation: while the Government gives practical support to Israel’s military aggression, large numbers oppose it.
Displaying a ‘Palestine Action’ poster doesn’t on its own save lives. It’s a symbolic action, expressing a moral claim. The moral claim is that our nation should stop supporting the killing of Gazans.
If nobody makes public claims about what is morally right or wrong, our society is the poorer. We become more likely to do the wrong thing because we haven’t thought it through.
As a Christian (well, my sort of Christian I am reminded that Christianity began with people getting arrested, prosecuted and killed for following Jesus. Mark’s gospel says:
As for yourselves, beware; for they will hand you over to councils; and you will be beaten in synagogues; and you will stand before governors and kings because of me, as a testimony to them… Brother will betray brother to death, and a father his child, and children will rise against parents and have them put to death; and you will be hated by all because of my name (Mark 13:9-13).
Biblical scholars have had two thousand years to argue that it wasn’t really that bad. The text can be interpreted as one big mistake, caused by the erroneous belief that God was about to intervene to bring in a new age.
But although some people did have this belief, they would not have been arrested. They would have been politically harmless. There would have been no reason to arrest and prosecute people who were predicting divine intervention. Jesus and some of his followers were arrested and killed because they really did offer a better alternative, thereby showing up the political establishment as the brutes they were.
Today, in the same way, the people who get arrested, prosecuted and punished are not the harmless ones. They are the ones who speak truth to power and draw attention to what the ruling class are doing wrong.
The British Government are not going to suppress a movement that claims the world is flat. The movements they want to suppress are the ones that draw attention to what they are doing wrong. They know their collusion with Israeli aggression is wrong. This is what we humans are like: knowing we are wrong makes us all the more determined to deny that we are wrong.
Sometimes there is a need to stand up for what is right, even at the risk of punishment. Not everybody can do it, but we can be grateful for those who do.
So what kind of person are you? Are you just not interested? Or do you think the Government are right? Is there a different issue you feel called to get stuck into? Or do you ask yourself what you can do to help?
I have two main reasons for not displaying a notice and therefore getting arrested: one is that as a then convicted terrorist sympathiser I would presumably have to cease to be a churchwarden and PCC member.
Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, I’d lose my shotgun license.