The medieval movement

This is an extract from my book How Jesus Liberated the Oppressed.

Throughout the Middle Ages Western Christianity had two faces. One retained the imperial theology inherited from the age of Constantine. It was led by popes and bishops with ruling class status. They established Catholic doctrines and defined heresies. The other retained the egalitarianism and simple lifestyles suspicious of wealth. We hear less from them, for the usual reasons: as most were illiterate their views were less often written down, and even when they were the ruling classes could suppress them.

Historically there is no clear dividing line between the two; but when we observe popes disliking renewal movements based on simple lifestyles while struggling to find just cause to forbid them, it is clear that the division has been established. By the end of the seventeenth century it was possible to believe that official Christianity was what Christian governments said it was, while ignoring Basil, Waldo, and Francis and treating Carlstadt and the Levelers as heretical extremists.

Nevertheless, it remains the case that when we compare the political leaders of this era with their predecessors and successors, their economic values stand out as distinctive. Their debates about which practices were morally acceptable, their condemnations of avarice, and their refusal to allow interest on loans did not exist at all in the way people did business in pagan Rome—and do not exist at all in the way people do business today.

Underlying the difference is a theology. Throughout the Middle Ages economic questions were hotly debated, but not in the way they are debated today. Wealth came from God, given to meet the needs of all. The central question was how to make sure it did, in the face of commercial practices favoring the powerful. The economic agenda was to make sure the powerless, and ordinary peasant farmers, received their share of God’s bounty.

In retrospect, what is most surprising about this story is how influential the Jesus movement remained, and for how long, despite opposition by the powerful. The common people who supported it, and benefited from it, were rarely literate. Most of what we read about them was written by their more powerful opponents. Yet they persisted throughout this period, bearing witness to the vision of a different kind of society.